Dr. Huxtable Is At It Again
May 18, 2006 by Marc Lamont Hill

It’s that time of year again.
Like the start of baseball season and the proliferation of “Down Low” propaganda, Bill Cosby’s rants against the Black poor are becoming a perennial feature of the impending summer. On the most recent stops along his 18-city “Call Out” tour, Cosby has reignited controversy by publicly attacking Black men.
While I don’t question his love for Black people, his recent actions have appeared more venomous than valuable, more condescending than caring, and more hateful than helpful.
During a recent speech at Spelman College’s commencement ceremony, Cosby further demonized Black men by labeling them as people who “send their sperm” but run from being fathers. On a recent CNN interview, Cosby criticized Black men who would rather “sell drugs than flip burgers.”
While at the University of the District of Columbia, Cosby completely lost it. According to the Washington Post, Cosby fielded a question from a disabled man who promptly criticized the “watered-down” nature of the dialogue and invoked the name Michael Eric Dyson, whose book “Is Bill Cosby Right” provided a principled and thorough response to Cosby’s public statements. Cosby responded by leaving the stage and hovering over the man’s wheelchair, retorting “You don’t deserve an audience with me. I’m not afraid of any Mr. Dyson.”
Perhaps he should be.
Unlike many Black leaders who praised Cosby’s comments, Dyson has rightly pointed out that Cosby’s claims were both mean spirited and lacking in nuance. Unfortunately, Cosby has been unwilling to engage in a public forum with Dyson or any other leaders who offer legitimate rejoinders to Cosby’s critically impoverished analysis of the Black poor.
What makes Cosby’s comments so problematic is that they are lightly dipped in truth. Of course, there are people who won’t work, father multiple children, and devalue education. (A visit to my family reunion, for example, will provide access to these and other social problems.) To be certain, Black people should not merely play the “blame game,” but work hard to improve and ultimately overcome their circumstances.
The problem, however, is that Cosby’s incessant citations of Black failings, in addition to being overstated, do not acknowledge the structural issues that undermine his gospel of individual responsibility. In fact, they largely serve to reinforce a public indifference and outright animus toward the Black poor that make it more difficult to enact self-help projects.
Hopefully, more Black leadership will have the courage to stand up and challenge Cosby.
- Categories: MLH
- |
Advertisement
8 Comments
1. SammyBee wrote:
The Bottom Line is: The TRUTH hurts. And people cant handle the truth. They’d rather make excuses for their situations than to do something about it.
May 19, 2006 @ 12:24 am2. SammyBee wrote:
what is a FOB?
May 19, 2006 @ 4:43 pm3. SammyBee wrote:
clearly I wasnt the only one that didnt catch on to the lingo. **chuckling on the inside**
May 19, 2006 @ 7:34 pm4. RAD wrote:
So what’s the other way Omodiende?
May 20, 2006 @ 1:35 am5. omodiende wrote:
i dunno RAD
May 20, 2006 @ 5:40 am6. RAD wrote:
Amen to that Theology…
May 23, 2006 @ 12:30 am7. ting wrote:
geezus freakin christmas, marlon could you please translate eVERYThing you just said! Shit, I got an enourmous headache just tryin to read that. Make your point without all the frills please. THANKS!
May 25, 2006 @ 3:17 pm8. Marlon Hill wrote:
Ting,
u might b full, but i aint–n bein FAM izz relevant on more den one level.
So u can know who u talkin 2, i’ma (IMMA izz EMMA) DEVOUT PanAfrikanist–dat make me big on FAM. Regardless of WHO fit WHERE in da HUMAN family, Afrikans got troubles (sic).
i wouldn’t discuss Afrikan problems with europeans (largely cuz dey got dey own problem of COLLECTIVELY reflectin da negative principality 2a terrible degree).
i’ll respect MHL’s blog by not domin u 4 yo tude.
Bobbin n weavin, i’ll add dat i can ENTIRELY relate 2 MHL bein left speechless by what somebody might say. i aint at a loss 4 words, i’m juss bitin my tongue (chewin my nails or sumpn).
May 28, 2006 @ 12:51 amLeave a Reply

- Advertise with us
- Advertise with us
Advertisements
Recent Comments
- WPD on Is The Occupy Wall Street Movement More Racist Than The Tea Party? said "Dr" Hill is pathetic.

- Esty on Is The Occupy Wall Street Movement More Racist Than The Tea Party? said Occupy Wall St. is just straight stupid. I work on ...

- F Mize on OPEN POST said Marc, I saw your interview on O'reilly tonight and ...

- View More Comments

