Original Dreamgirls Feel Dissed
November 22, 2006 by Marc Lamont Hill
By Clay Cane
Jennifer Holliday, who made the role of Effie White famous in the legendary 1982 Broadway musical Dreamgirls is NOT GOING when it comes to the role she gave breath, flesh and life. Many of the original cast members from the groundbreaking musical are feeling ignored by the creators of the film, which hits theatres nationwide Christmas Day. For Holliday, Effie White is the best role she EVER HAD and she will tear down the mountains, yell, scream and shout it. In an exclusive interview with Inside Edition Wednesday, November 22nd (check your local listings) she will detail some of her concerns. Supposedly there were “promises” made to Holliday when the film was in production, like a possible cameo, or even an actual role — none of that happened. However, when promoting the film early in the year the original “And I Am Telling You” was used for the trailers, which I remember thinking, “Why are they using this version?” The creators of Dreamgirls have used Holliday’s amazing voice (it is CUTE for Jenny Hudson and a good rendition — but her version isn’t even a Krispy Kreme crumb of Jennifer Holliday!) to promote the film, but according to Holliday her unforgettable contributions have been unrecognized. To make matters worse Holliday, and the two other original Dreamgirls, Sheryl Lee Ralph and Loretta Divine, weren’t even invited to the premiere!
Many might think, “Who cares – this was 25 years ago!” On the other hand, when Dreamgirls hit Broadway it was a watershed moment in African-American history and Broadway history. Never before had a musical arrived on Broadway starring three black women — it never happened again. Holliday’s Tony Award Winning performance made her a legend overnight so it is odd that the creators of the film are not showing the original cast common respect for the history. Sheryl Lee Ralph, who played Beyonce’s role of Deena, said in a March 2006 interview with Rockacandy.com: “In the 1980’s when D
reamgirls opened we completely changed theater, we changed who came to the theater, and who was interested in theater. And now 25 years later, people find it so easy to act like we didn’t do what we did.” While I am ecstatic a high-budget film surrounding three black women is making it to the silver screen with huge promotion, I am deeply confused on how Ralph, Holliday and Divine are being so quickly disregarded. In the 2002 film Chicago Chita Rivera, who originated the role of Velma Kelly on Broadway in 1975, made a cameo as “Nicky.” As much as the film has been compared to Chicago why aren’t Jennifer Holliday and the other women not even given a ticket to the premiere? In many ways the film should be a tribute to the original — obviously without the original there would be no film!
- Categories: MLH
- |
Advertisement
11 Comments
1. ChgoSista wrote:
I’ve been (and will continue) watching this story bubble… I expect things will bubble even more as the date of the movie release approaches. Whew!!!
I’m feelin’ Sheryl’s point(s).
November 22, 2006 @ 9:56 am2. Blaxx wrote:
Give me a break. I dismissed this article as soon as the whole light-skinned vs. dark-skinned argument came up (as I knew it would). If she is mad that the creators broke a promise that is one thing but she acts like they are obliged to keep her in the loop as to what they are doing with the movie. Then Clay Cane runs off on some mild Beyonce hating, even though everything I’ve heard about the movie so far is about Jennifer Hudson’s performance. And WTF is up with the colors?!?
November 22, 2006 @ 10:32 am3. Kristalogy wrote:
What about The Wiz? Didn’t that precede Dreamgirls? I’m not sure what they want here?
November 22, 2006 @ 11:26 am4. ChgoSista wrote:
Just re-read Cane’s piece and your posts. Don’t wanna over-analyze but NOW, my questions are:
1. Is Sheryl’s issue that the ‘powers that be’ slighted her or that OPRAH, the cast, etc., slighted her?
2. What’s wrong with Sheryl, Loretta, Jennifer Hudson, et al, wanting a little ’shine’?
3. Does she feel that it is/was incumbent upon maybe say, Beyonce, Jamie or Eddie to do/say SOMETHING?
5. ChgoSista wrote:
Okay… I meant Jennifer HOLLIDAY….
November 22, 2006 @ 12:14 pm6. Brooklyn101 wrote:
Chgo, I do wonder how it is she wants to recognized, though…
November 22, 2006 @ 12:43 pm7. ChgoSista wrote:
San–w/u totally… (re: cameo appearance)
November 22, 2006 @ 2:24 pm8. Blaxx wrote:
The only beef I think she is justified in having is that they promised her a cameo appearance and reneged on that. Otherwise, just sour grapes
November 22, 2006 @ 2:55 pm9. Brooklyn101 wrote:
Aww Blaxx, that’s like saying Run DMC or LL shouldn’t be acknowledged if they were to remake Krush Groove.
Why do you think all these award shows have those Legacy Awards and such? To honor the ones who came before us. It just so happens that Sheryl Lee Ralph couldn’t wait for her legacy award, she wants her honors now!
November 22, 2006 @ 4:52 pm10. Chuckaluck wrote:
I ma sure when the movie was in development… at least two of the three were offred SOMETHING, however, they probably never rec’d the call because of their greedy agents,
December 3, 2006 @ 5:55 pm11. Fear Factory - Soul Of A New Machine (2004 remastered) wrote:
robin Fear Factory – Soul Of A New Machine (2004 remastered) good …
July 11, 2007 @ 9:27 amLeave a Reply

- Advertise with us
- Advertise with us
Advertisements
Recent Comments
- WPD on Is The Occupy Wall Street Movement More Racist Than The Tea Party? said "Dr" Hill is pathetic.

- Esty on Is The Occupy Wall Street Movement More Racist Than The Tea Party? said Occupy Wall St. is just straight stupid. I work on ...

- F Mize on OPEN POST said Marc, I saw your interview on O'reilly tonight and ...

- View More Comments

